Homemade Natural Creamy Peanut Butter
Made with Dry Roasted Virginia #2 peanuts — no artificial sweeteners, no hydrogenated oil and just a little salt, made exactly like it was 100 years ago. No-salt too.
About us
Traveling back in time, on Elm Street.
In 1915, John S. Zimmerman began selling candy and homemade peanut butter in his new general store in Penbrook. Shortly after opening, Zimmerman’s purchased a roaster and a couple of mills for peanuts — peanuts were a novel thing then — and began making peanut butter.
In 1968 and 1969, Lee’s parents expanded the candy selection, bringing in Asher’s Chocolates of Lewistown and Necco Confections. Today Zimmerman’s has chocolates and penny candy as far as the eye can see.
